Leave the World Behind released
Rumaan Alam’s novel, “Leave the World Behind” released in the tumultuous year of 2020, presented a gripping psychological narrative involving two New York families forced together in a secluded rural vacation home amidst a vaguely defined, potentially catastrophic event.
Despite its premise, the book wasn’t strictly a science-fiction thriller; it stayed grounded in its characters’ emotions, offering a more human-centered apocalypse. Yet, glimpses of the outside world’s chaos in the narrative added a cosmic urgency to the story of Leave the World Behind. Film adaptations don’t inherently owe fidelity to their source material.
Nevertheless, constant alterations solely for the worse can prove vexing to those familiar with the original work. Sam Esmail’s adaptation of “Leave the World Behind” takes Alam’s characters and plot but veers into a more pronounced, albeit unconvincing, apocalyptic thriller. Amanda (Julia Roberts) and Clay (Ethan Hawke), an affluent Brooklyn couple, rent a rural vacation home with their teenagers.
Strange occurrences begin to unfold, notably a massive tanker grounding on a nearby beach. Soon after, George (Mahershala Ali) and his daughter Ruth (Myha’la Herrold) arrive seeking shelter, revealing themselves as the property’s owners after a city-wide blackout. Amanda, suspicious of the newcomers, contrasts with Clay’s more accommodating nature.
Regrettably, the film Leave the World Behind lacks any genuine interest or empathy toward its characters. They exist more as cardboard cutouts embodying postures than eliciting sympathy or human connection. While Alam’s novel delves into the intricate collisions and cohesion between the families, Esmail’s film initially seems to explore the opposite, separating them to witness individual experiences of the unfolding apocalypse.
However, these characters remain hollow, inserted into disaster sequences without embodying genuine human reactions. Even as they attempt to bond later in the film, it feels contrived and lacks authenticity. The film’s success might have hinged on compelling, convincing depictions of the apocalypse on screen.
Unfortunately, Esmail uses ambiguity as a storytelling crutch, piling bizarre events without clarifying their significance. Consequently, it feels disjointed, a mere collection of disconnected ideas rather than a cohesive narrative. Though there are occasional intriguing elements, like an endless traffic jam of driverless Teslas, these moments fail to salvage the overall film.
Ultimately, the lack of believability extends beyond the incidents to the characters themselves and their dialogue. Esmail’s attempts to shape the material to fit his vision rather than embracing its essence leave the audience disconnected. The film’s visual artistry, while impressive, feels detached from the emotional core of the story.
In contrast, similar adaptations like M. Night Shyamalan’s “A Knock at the Cabin” excelled by maintaining focus on the characters’ nuances, creating a more engaging and affecting experience. “Leave the World Behind” aspires to present a panoramic view of humanity, yet Esmail’s treatment, rooted in specificity and interiority, falls short.
The depth and intricacy of Alam’s characterizations are lost in translation, leading to disjointed character behavior and an overly expositional script. The talented cast struggles to breathe life into these poorly developed personas, leaving viewers questioning their significance and the filmmaker’s intentions.
In moments like Amanda’s peculiar monologue expressing disdain for people, one wonders if the writer-director inadvertently speaks about himself rather than the characters’ authentic voices. The disconnect between the film Leave the World Behind and its source material becomes increasingly evident as the narrative progresses.
The intricacies that made the characters in Alam’s novel tangible and relatable are sorely absent. Amanda’s brittle paranoia and Clay’s adaptable nature, which felt rooted in the novel’s pages, seem like mere outlines in the film, lacking the depth that would engage audiences. In the book, George and Ruth, portrayed as an older married couple, exuded a weary vulnerability that added layers to the escalating tension.
However, in Leave the World Behind without this context, their actions and dynamics lose their resonance, leaving these characters feeling unfamiliar and underdeveloped. While acknowledging that movies and books are distinct entities with different creators, the film fails to justify the behaviors of its characters, leaving viewers questioning their motivations.
Despite the talented cast’s efforts, the dialogue they’re tasked with delivering feels forced and overly explanatory, hindering any chance of authentic emotional resonance. As the story unfolds, there’s a sense of unfulfilled potential.
Esmail’s inclination to impose his vision on the narrative rather than letting the essence of the story guide him leads to a discordant and disjointed film experience. Even the cinematography, although visually striking, feels detached from the emotional core, lacking a genuine connection to the unfolding drama.
Comparisons with other adaptations, like M. Night Shyamalan’s nuanced approach in a similar genre, highlight the missed opportunities in Esmail’s interpretation. Shyamalan’s careful use of offscreen space and gradual revelation of narrative information heightened the tension, creating an immersive and haunting experience that resonated deeply with audiences.
“Leave the World Behind” seemingly aims for a grandiose portrayal of humanity, but Esmail’s adaptation, built on specifics and introspection, misses the mark. The meticulous attention to detail in Alam’s novel is lost in translation, resulting in characters that lack depth and a story that fails to engage on an emotional level.
In essence, the film “Leave the World Behind” struggles to capture the essence of the novel, leaving audiences detached and questioning the filmmaker’s intentions. Despite the potential for a thought-provoking exploration of human nature amid catastrophe, Esmail’s adaptation falls short, failing to evoke the same depth and emotional impact as its source material.
Kadak Singh review : Pankaj Tripathi Shines in This Riveting and Realistic Thriller!
